HOME    REVIEWS    LETTERS    ABOUT    CONTACT   



Frankenstein Meets The Wolf Man

Frankenstein Meets The Wolf Man

The Company Line

It is described as "one of the great classic horror films of the 1940s." Bela Lugosi is the Frankenstein monster and Lon Chaney, Jr. is the Wolf Man. The Wolf Man has been brought back to life and seeks a cure for his problem so he "enlists the aid of [a] mad scientist, who claims he will not only rid the Wolf Man of his nocturnal metamorphosis but will also revive the frozen body of Frankenstein's inhuman creation." "This is a chiller for fans of all ages."

1943, 73 minutes, VHS

The Review

Universal must have realized after the dreadful The Ghost of Frankenstein, that their big green dope was probably too played out a concept to successfully carry a picture on his own anymore. The solution was too take the onus off of the Monster and have a different monster carry the load in this movie. They turned to the Wolf Man who hadn't appeared in a movie since his debut outing way back in 1941. So they had Lon Chaney get out of the Monster's make up that he had donned for The Ghost of Frankenstein and put back in the fangs and hairy wig. As for the now vacant role of the Monster, since Bela Lugosi's brain had already been implanted in the beast at the end of the last movie, they decided to just go all the way and have him play the Monster himself. This must have so sweet for Lugosi who turned down the role in the original movie, only to see Boris Karloff do it and become a bigger star than he. I mean, at long last he got to show the world what would have happened if he wasn't too snooty to have done it in the first place. After checking out his constipated lumbering around in this movie and completely wooden performance, I think it's safe to say that if he had originally did it, there wouldn't have been six sequels. The movie of course makes little sense from a continuity stand point and contradictions with previous films abound. We're not sure what time period this takes place in. It's stated that these events take place about four years after the story depicted in The Wolf Man. But I think that film was set in modern times. All these Frankenstein movies are set before that, I assume at various points in the nineteenth century. The rest of these problems can be addressed as they crop up.

First and foremost, you should realize that this is really a sequel to The Wolf Man and as far as the Frankenstein Monster goes, he's merely a supporting character. This means you get lots of scenes of Lon Chaney, Jr. reprising the Larry Talbot gimmick, which involves a lot of sweaty hyper activity as he alternately tries to convince everyone that he is a werewolf and bitches and moans about how awful he has it and why won't somebody kill him? I should also add that at times, Lon resembles Shemp Howard. Since this is one of those "classic" Universal horror movies, everything starts out with a grave-robbing scene. Two guys bust into the Talbot crypt and get into Larry's coffin. They are somewhat startled to see the fleshy corpse of Larry covered in wolfbane. Did I mention that the night they decided to go tomb raiding was the night of a full moon? One of the guys takes a ring form Larry, then Larry grabs the guy and won't let go. The other dude escapes ("Uh, I'll go and get some help. I'll be right back.") and leaves the hapless thief with Larry and you can imagine how that turns out. Later, Talbot is found in the street sleeping off his Wolf Man bender and he is transported to the hospital. It is there that we are introduced to Dr. Mannering, a psychiatrist or something (later, he inexplicably turns into a mad scientist) who checks out Talbot. Talbot tells them who he is and where he's from, but when they check out that info, they are told that Talbot died four years ago. Assuming that he is some type of imposter as opposed to a resurrected Wolf Man (the most obvious answer), the cops hang around and threaten to question Larry periodically about this and that. Later at night, Larry sees the full moon (lots of full moons in Britain, I guess) and gets a hankering to go take a bite out of someone. A cop (they call them Bobbies for some reason - with their little whistles and pointy hats, I'd call them Nancies) sees this hairy dude hopping around, jumping from street corner to street corner and the next thing you now, Larry has taken a bite out of crime. Larry believes that he killed the cop (because he did), but no one believes him and surprisingly enough no one believes that he is the Wolf Man (nah, he's gotta be taller and in better shape). He tries to escape to go get himself some help (That hospital has too many nosy cops and not enough sexy nurses!), but they put him in a straight jacket. Later that night he busts out and goes in search of Maleva, the old gypsy whose son bit him and turned him into a werewolf.

After looking Maleva up on the internet, Larry locates her at a gypsy encampment somewhere outside the town of Europe. He's like, "hey how've you been, can you neuter the Wolf Man in me?" She's like, "Lon, you look a little puffy, too many Kibbles and Bits? No, I can't do it, but there is this mad scientist I hear good things about. Name of Frankenstein or something." So there we have it. Larry Talbot is going to seek out Dr. Frankenstein to fix his lycanthropy. Of course the question is which Frankenstein is this? Henry? Dead. Wolf? Not dead that we know of, but Basil Rathbone isn't in this picture so that makes the odds pretty slim, plus we haven't heard from him since the third movie. Ludwig? Dead. There is one Frankenstein that is alive and well and apparently in this movie. Elsa, Ludwig's daughter. Maybe she went to medical school instead of lounging around her dad's sanitarium trying to hook up with the local prosecutor. Well, the Wolf Man runs away from Maleva, killing a girl since it's another full moon and he ends up falling into the snowy ruins of the Frankenstein estate. This is supposedly the crazy house that Ludwig ran in the last movie, but somehow it has turned from a manor-type house into a big old castle built right below a dam. The first time I saw that this castle was built right next to a model dam, I was immediately blowing up my inner tube and slipping on my Speedos, because you and I know that any dam in a monster movie (see also: most Godzilla movies), that thing is going to come crashing down, leveling everything in an ending that leaves the door open for whatever monster was caught up in the deluge to wash up on the shores of another sequel. I was hoping that Lon could use Bela's inflated ego as a floatation device. The icy ruins beneath the burned out castle are a nice piece of set design and give you something that you hadn't seen before in this series (a welcome relief after all the dungeons, secret labs, and Burgermeisters). The Wolf Man hops around a little checking it out, but I guess the moon wears off on him, because then we see Lon taking a nap in what looks like really, cold slushy water somewhere in the ruins. He gets up and wipes the snow off a wall of ice and sees the Monster frozen in there. He busts the monster out and he tells the Monster that he needs Frankenstein's secret diary so that he can read the notes about the experiments and find a way to finally be dead for good (Larry's always had a defeatist attitude.). Right away, you can see that this movie ignores the Frankenstein films that have gone before. When last seen, the Monster had Ygor's brain and could speak, just like Ygor. He also was blind, because of a blood incompatibility between Ygor and the Monster (don't ask). This Monster shows none of the intelligence that was transplanted into it with Ygor's brain. He can't talk, just points a lot and grunts and howls, but he can see just fine. Apparently there were plans for the Monster to speak, and I guess a few of those scenes were shot, but the idea of Bela's voice coming from the Monster was too retarded for even this movie. Of course that ignores the fact that climatic scenes of the previous film featured Lugosi's voiced dubbed onto Lon Chaney's Monster to portray the idea that the Monster now had Ygor's brain. Anyway, as you might expect, the whiney Larry Talbot and the dimwitted Monster are unable to locate the doctor's diary.

Teaming up with a mental midget of a monster doesn't look like it's going to get Larry Talbot anywhere so he cleans himself up, gets a new suit (How did he afford that on a Wolf Man's salary?) and arranges with the mayor (Lionel Atwill making his patented Frankenstein movie appearance) to meet Elsa Frankenstein, now called the Baroness since everyone else has croaked. This is another bit of interesting revisionist history. When we last laid eyes on her, Elsa was played by Evelyn Ankers, wore gowns, dated a prosecutor and talked regular old English. This new Elsa is played by Ilona Massey, wears furs and gaudy jewelry, speaks in a thick accent, and there's nary a boyfriend in sight. You may recall that accent being a little more appropriate when she played a German hussy in Invisible Agent. Talbot pretends like he wants to buy the Frankenstein estate from her so that she will meet with him and give him the dead doctor's secret formulas. She's a bit skeptical, but since there's this festival going on that night, they hang out and we get to listen to an awful musical number that actually drives Talbot insane! With the audience's heart-felt thanks, he tells this singer that he is no A.J. from the BSBs and to shut his pie-hole. Finally, Dr. Mannering shows up and tells Larry that he is whacko and a killer and Larry goes "duh." At some point in all this the Monster appears for some reason to do who knows what (I'll bet Bela was just hungry for screen time and showed up on his own!). Larry hops on a wagon full of barrels, gets the Monster in there and has the horses haul their monstrous arses out of there. The townspeople immediately start organizing into an angry, uncontrollable mob (they're still irked by the death of this kid that the Wolf Man caused as well as being prejudiced against Frankensteins in general) and demand that the mayor let them at the Baroness (I'm betting that was mostly the guys who were demanding that!). The mayor says he'll talk to her and find out what the deal is. She agrees to help and she and Dr. Mannering go up to the ruins to find Larry and the Monster. There she locates the secret book, Mannering agrees to some questionable experiment that will supposedly drain the life out of both the Monster and the Wolf Man. I'm not sure how they conned the town into waiting while all this scientific equipment is FedExed in, but they all wait and watch as these mysterious lights start blinking over at the castle.

Dr. Mannering gets everything powered up (the water from the dam is turning some turbines) and he's got both the Monster and Larry Talbot strapped down. I really don't recall why the Monster went along with all this, he seemed to have an aversion to being killed in at least some of the sequels (but not in Bride Of Frankenstein). The script takes several liberties with common sense in this portion of the film. For one thing, Mannering is doing the big experiment the evening of a full moon. You would think, that knowing this, he would have set his alarm clock about an hour earlier so that he could get drain the juice from Larry before he turned into the Wolf Man. I guess he just didn't want to miss The View. Now, the other problem arises when Mannering has all the cables connected up (he reads the instructions to himself out loud: "negative to negative, positive to positive"). He decides at the last instant that he can't destroy the Monster and wants to see what that baby can do when fully charged, so he reverses everything, throwing a bunch of power into the Monster. This of course makes absolutely no sense for the character to behave this way, except that it provides a reason for the Monster to break free and tangle with the Wolf Man. Here was a guy who was all about treating Talbot and worried about him being a homicidal maniac and now he's energizing the Frankenstein Monster? The Monster busts loose, Talbot turns into the Wolf Man, the roll around on the floor together in one of those cruddy movie monster fights (though the Wolf Man is much more spry than Lon Chaney's doughy body would indicate). One of the villagers gets fed up waiting around for the mad scientist to destroy the Monster ("Hello? I'm busy making him all better!"), picks up a wad of dynamite from the 7-11 and blows up the dam sending cupfuls of water crashing into a model of the castle, burying the two monsters inside, but allowing Elsa to escape (for the second movie in a row!) as well as her mad scientist pal (so much for punishing evil). Though not nearly the slagheap the previous film was, it's obvious that this film strains credulity in most of its major story points. Bela Lugosi further cements his and the Monster's reputations as has-beens with this unmemorably generic performance. That could have been anyone under that make-up stumbling around like he had a corn cob up his butt. The Monster has been completely stripped of any of the depth that made him an interesting character and he does little other than stand awkwardly around, periodically swinging his arms menacingly like the dumbest of flesh eating zombies that seemed to dominate undead movies of the seventies and eighties. At least Larry Talbot still resembles the character he was in The Wolf Man, his plight making the film a little more interesting than than the green paint-by numbers affair of some of the other sequels. But do they further the Wolf Man mythos or character any in this film? Not really, Larry's still crying in his beer about what's happened to him and begs everyone else to do the work for him. I don't really see Larry taking any affirmative steps on his own to kill himself. I mean, if you want to die, then do it. Don't try to cajole everyone else into doing it. If you don't want to die, but want to find a solution, get off your butt and do that. I don't see why he thinks a guy who created a monster, but failed to destroy it after four attempts is the answer. That said, it was probably as good a reason as any to get these two monsters together. I still think these monster team-up pictures are a lot better in theory than in practice. Monster movies work when you are able to concentrate on a single monster, its problems, its threats, and the way people deal with it. When you add a couple of more monsters to the mix, it reduces screen time for everyone, taxes your suspension of disbelief (All of Universal's monsters existed in their own respective universes when they started, at least you could believe that Godzilla and all his pals were from the same reality, after all, they even had their very own island!), and waters down the concept of every monster involved. Is it fun to watch? I suppose there's a segment of the viewing public that thinks so, but if you watch this and compare it to the quality of the first, second, or even third movie, you can't help but be let down. After The Ghost of Frankenstein, this probably reinvigorated the series (for about two more movies), but only due to curiosity, not because of any inventiveness or quality. This film sealed this series fate. The only thing left to do was add more monsters and that's exactly what they did. And like anything else, the novelty finally wore off and these films were revealed to be merely soulless husks of their classic forefathers.

Reviews © 2004 MonsterHunter