HOME    REVIEWS    LETTERS    ABOUT    CONTACT   



Island Of Lost Souls

The Company Line

They acknowledge the source material here (H.G. Wells' novel The Island of Dr. Moreau ) and note that the book was banned in some countries and parts of the United States. Dr. Moreau is described as " a benign-looking doctor who lives and works on his own private South Seas island." A shipwreck strands Eward Parker on the island and he learns about the "hideous experiments" that the "benign-looking" doctor conducts in his lab called "The House of Pain". Parker runs into a panther woman, Moreau decides to try to see if he can have these two procreate. Soon his island of creatures begin to rebel and Moreau "could become the next victim of his own twisted creations."

1933, 71 minutes, VHS

The Review

This video is touted as being part of the Universal Studios Monsters Collection. That is actually something of a misnomer. Paramount Studios made this movie in 1932 and Universal, knowing a good thing when they saw it, bought it later and repackaged it with their classic horror films of the period ( Frankenstein, Dracula, The Mummy ) and it stands up with the best of those films. It tells the story of a man picked up at sea, Edward Parker (Richard Arlen), by a ship heading to the uncharted island inhabited by the mysterious Dr. Moreau. For some reason, the ship's captain, a grubby sea-lout if there ever was one, didn't feel like hauling Parker's carcass back to the mainland where he could reunite with his woman. So, when he stops at Moreau's island, he punches out Parker and walks his ass off the plank and onto Moreau's boat and then he leaves, chuckling (tis no man, but a remorseless beast!). So Parker and Moreau are left staring at each other, mouths agape. Moreau ferries him to the main part of his island and tells him that his doctor assistant will take him back to the mainland in the morning.

Of course, since this is a mysterious uncharted island, Moreau tells Parker that he must not roam around the island, for his own safety. Parker begins to think something might be amiss when he notices that all the natives are half-man, half-beast. "Hmm, that guy looks like a dog and that other guy a gorilla and that one has a cloven hoof. Why, the natives here are an odd lot, almost as if they're the product of some sick scientific plot gone horribly wrong. Probably just my imagination." Now, I would have known something was up the first time I laid eyes on that tubby Moreau character poured into his ice cream white suit and decked out with a simpering goatee. I also think that the fact that he was making like Indiana Jones with his bullwhip whenever the natives barked and growled in his direction was a dead giveaway that we had an evil genius on our hands.

You see, what Dr. Moreau does on his island is experiments of unspeakable horror! He takes animals such as apes and lions and tries to turn them into people by operating on them! He even was able to get some of them to talk with his special operations. Setting aside the dubiousness of whether that would ever work (it wouldn't), the concept behind it is relevant today, even more so than in 1932 when this movie was first released. Already we've seen the cloned sheep Dolly survive with no apparent problems and you see reports almost daily of some sicko freaky thing some sicko freaky "scientist" has dreamed up in his secret government lab: mice with paws growing out of their backs, mice engineered with the genes of jellyfish, WWF brand meat snack sticks made partly with ostrich meat (original or teriyaki flavors!). Yep, this is one of those, "man shouldn't play god" movies. And really in this case it's a good idea. I mean, do we really need to be creating scuzzy looking subhumans that are dumb as dirt? Don't we already have the South?

Moreau, like any good scientist is wanting to take the next step in his research. He's managed to populate the island with all these grunting losers and he's all like, "boring!" When Parker shows up, Moreau gets the bright idea to introduce him to Lota. "Parker, my good man, I know just the perfect panther-woman for you. She's got smoldering good looks, doesn't talk a lot, and you should see her claws, I mean nails." So, Moreau sets him up on a blind date with Lota and leaves them alone to get to know one another. And Moreau is hoping that they get to know one another in a biblical sense. Apparently, he's gotten it into his head that the next big thing is to breed a human with one of his creatures. Now, why would that be a good idea? Anyway, they get in a clinch and Parker notices that she has claws instead of fingers or something and gets all creeped out by it. Rejected, Lota goes bawling to Moreau who is initially outraged but is then impressed with his handiwork because one of his creatures can cry.

Charles Laughton as Dr. Moreau delivers a great performance here as a scientist bent on doing his research at all costs. He literally is playing god on his island, a hidden Eden where he is the master and the Law. He controls his subjects through fear and physcial punishment. All the creatures know of "The House Of Pain" where Moreau makes his "adjustments" to his subjects and they fear and hate him for it. Moreau is one of those guys so sure of his genius that he doesn't see that there is about to be a revolt by his creatures and fails to recognize the inevitabilty that people outgrow their gods and destroy them to announce their passage from child to adult. He also isn't real smart in that he doesn't seem to realize that one fat guy with a bullwhip against an island full of hellish creations isn't going to get you the greatest point spread in Vegas. Bela Lugosi is in this movie a gives a good performance as he's buried underneath a wig and fake beard and only has about twelve lines of dialogue, thus keeping the ham and cheese to minimum in this picture. This movie is better by far than the subsequent versions including the Brando version which was as bloated and understandable as its star (a lot and not at all). The cautionary message about science run amok and science without reason still resonates. The movie never explained Moreau's motives regarding his experiments. He seemed to be doing them just show the people who booted his lard ass out of London that he could do it. I think it was because he had a self-image problem and all the animals he tried to remake into perfect humans were substitutes for himself. Naturally he failed in all his attempts, becuase he needed to change what was inside of him, not his physical appearance (though he was kind of icky), and eventually all his failures and self loathing finally destroyed him.

Reviews © 2004 MonsterHunter