HOME    REVIEWS    LETTERS    ABOUT    CONTACT   



Reunion In France

Reunion In France

The Company Line

They claim that Joan Crawford and John Wayne are an "electrifying screen duo" in this movie about the "gallantry displayed by the French" after they get their country taken over by the Nazis. The compare this to Casablanca and say that Reunion In France is a "vivid love story and a nail-biting suspense tale." Crawford plays rich French woman that hides Wayne in her apartment after he gets shot down flying for the RAF. She tries to get her rich boyfriend to help them out. "But then the dark mist of betrayal permeates the proceedings, obscuring all love and allegiance."

1942, 100 minutes, VHS

The Review

In wartime, you have to pull out all the stops. The conventional wisdom has to be discarded in an effort to surprise the enemy and catch him napping. You have to be able to think outside the box and come up with that one-two punch they'll never see coming. In World War II, Hollywood eagerly joined up with America and her allies in an effort to whip a little Axis tail and they too wanted to launch their own assaults trumpeting freedom, courage, and sacrifice. Unfortunately, sometimes the audience suffered a little friendly fire, took one for the team, became some collateral damage. How else to explain the excruciatingly unsuccessful teaming of Joan Crawford and John Wayne in a movie about occupied France? This was one of those flicks that I snickered at and eagerly snapped up as soon as I saw the cover where Crawford has one of those noble wartime poses, that says "I will survive this movie with John Wayne" while Wayne looks likes he's searching for the goof that thought it would be a good idea to have him dressed up as a chauffeur for a good portion of the movie (Why do I have the sneaking suspicion that Joan suggested that?). As pointless as it was to probably be involved with making this movie, at least they probably got a little bread out of the deal. The movie going public though was forced to pay good money for this one that could have been better spent on munitions, medicine or since this was 1942 and the Jerries were running roughshod over those wusses in Europe, German language lessons. As I was watching this one, I began to understand why the French people are usually a pretty crabby people and complain whenever we import out superior culture to them (Disneyland and Big Macs). You see, unlike America who got a big W in World War II and came out the top babyface (even if it did take us forever to get involved in it) in the world (the whining of the commies and third world excepted, but they were just jealous, right?), France has to live with the fact that they rolled over on their own country like Sammy The Bull getting immunity for testifying against the Dapper Don. I think I speak for all Americans when I watched the scene of the Nazis marching through the Arc de Triumph (Did the Germans name that?) and and was sickened by the Frenchies' utter lack of pride. If those Teutonic worms had the balls to try to march through the Arch in St. Louis, you can bet that me, Nelly, Harry Truman and every other red blooded Missourian would have been down there with our Saturday Night Specials sending them back to the Fuhrer via the Big Muddy. Then we'd head over to the east side to see the Lay-dies!

Really though, I'm not here to complain about Dirty Pierre getting a case of the limber tail sixty years ago, but when I gots to sit through some propaganda movie designed to make me feel like you people were pulling your weight in the war and that means that Joan Crawford is going to be playing a character named Michelle de la Becque and affecting a faint to non-existent accent, then I'm going to get a little lippy. If Crawford's character is supposed to represent all that is great about the French people than I have to wonder why we ever busted our hump to rescue them. You see, she's one of those fair-weather patriots that "rises" to the occasion only when the war is smacking her upside the head and her boyfriend has turned traitor. Before this, Nazis were sweeping over the rest of Europe and Joan's biggest concern was that she was going to have to start getting her silk imported in a diplomatic pouch or something. The first part of the movie strenuously tries establish her character as a rich, thoughtless, self-centered jerk (How am I supposed to buy Joan in a role like that?). They do this in all the usual ways - mainly by having her mistreat the hired help at the department store that supplies all her beautiful gowns (supposedly the gowns were the only positive experience for Joan while making this film). You don't think that once everyone in Paris starts running around with their "Nazi World Tour '40" concert tees on that she'll have to slink back to these gals and recognize that they really are good people even though they're poor French trash, do you? I'll bet that they're such solid citizens that they will even help Joan out when she needs it, instead of reporting her to the Nazis as a some kind of hoochie-spy and getting her shot, like anyone of us would have done (well, if we were French that is). Joan has a fiancee named Robert Cortot who is some type of engineering genius and also really rich. He babbles all the time about how busy he is and ships Joan off to Spain so that he can help win the war. When the Nazis take France like some twelve-year old girl soused on two wine coolers, Joan slinks back home. This is when the movie plays the war out in a bunch of spinning newspaper headlines, scenes of Joan stumbling around with dirt on her face (The horror of war!) amid a bunch of scurvy refugees including a little kid with a missing foot (Those damn Nazis!). When she gets back home, Robert is busy with the war effort, but now it's the Nazi war effort!

Oh, Robert (say it Ro-bare)! Say it isn't so! Joan, having been a war refugee for about a week, has changed and is now superpatriot A#1 and can barely contain her contempt for the occupying Germans that Robert introduces her to (one of them is even John Carradine!). He takes her to a really sweet cocktail party that he's hosting and she is shocked, just shocked that it is a Nazi dinner party. The only question I have about these Nazi dinner parties is whether they really arranged their dining tables in the shape of a swastika? That seemed a bit much, but even though these were French collaboraters we were dealing with, I was still enraged enough that I was ready to sign up and get shipped over there to send those losers back to Berlin. Don't they know how tough a table arrangement like that is for the help to properly serve the various courses? Half the guests are always going to have to be staring at the waiter's backside whenever they're bringing out the croque monsieurs and the snails. What barbarians! With Joan's new found sense of French pride, she leaves her fiancee and goes back to her own mansion. What I like about her is that she was apparently all jacked up to have a big, fancy dinner party even though her country had been conquered until she found out that it was going to be Germans and their running dogs. Boy, have you changed Michelle! Sometimes I don't even think I know who you are anymore! When she gets back to her house, she discovers that the horrors of war have struck her right where she lives! The Nazis have commandeered her house for some administrative offices and now she is allowed only one room in the entire mansion. She chooses the concierge's room , since it has its own entrance to the street and you begin to understand why she hates the Nazis (first they throw bad dinner parties, now they're in her house). How much can one shallow, rich, snob be expected to endure? When I saw her looking around her new digs and that the Nazis had defaced the paintings on the wall by drawing little Hitler mustaches and pathetic comb-overs on the people's faces, I began looking at the clock and wondering when in the hell the Duke would show up to save France.

Duke Wayne finally appears about half way through this film as an RAF pilot who got shot down over France and is now on the run from the Krauts. He's being trailed by some German agents (why don't they just arrest him?) and he hasn't eaten or slept in awhile when he runs into Michelle. After a little back and forth, she takes him into her place and gives him some food and a bed. She finds out his identity from some handy-dandy disk that he's secreted away in the heel of his shoe and she immediately decides that she should go ask the gals at her new job for their help in getting the Duke back to England so he can resume getting his arse shot back down by the Red Baron. Job? That's right! Michelle has made such a complete change in the way she thinks about life that she even stoops to getting a job as a fitter's assistant at the department store where she used to torment the help. Wow, I really admire her for all the personal growth - a real life grown-up job! These moments are some of the most amusing in the movie as they show all these fat German broads coming into the shop wanting the latest fashions. We all know they're evil because only skinny French chicks should wear cutting edge gowns and fur coats. One of the German broads (if they aren't fat and nasty, they're old and nasty) is played by Natalie Schafer, whom you will recall as Mrs. Howell from Gilligan's Island. Oh, how this movie cried out for Jim Backus. She was basically doing a humorless version of Lovey in this one. At this point I shut the movie down for about an hour and half and busted out my collection of Gilligan's Island videos and watched my favorite episode three times (the one with the headhunters). Grudgingly, I returned to this movie and wondered if Duke Wayne was going to do anything besides hiding in the closet getting off on how Michelle's dresses smelled. For some reason Duke starts hitting on Michelle (Aren't you supposed to be trying to escape back to Britain or something?), but she's pulling a wholly unconvincing gimmick about how there's no time for love in war or some such baloney. Duke gets in a little he-man action though when he decks the drunk and amorous Nazi that has taken over the rest of Michelle's pad. Then she concocts a plan to get Robert (even though he's a traitor) to help her and the Duke get out of France.

I never understood why she thought this plan would work or why she thought that Robert would want to help her after she punked him just because he went and looked out for number one. Then I didn't understand why Robert actually did help her. But what really eluded me was why in tarnation anyone would believe that Duke Wayne was not only a American college student, but a chauffeur as well. The Nazis weren't buying it either and tried to doublecross all involved, but since this is a propaganda movie, the doublecross was really on them! See, it turns out that Robert is really a good guy and is only pretending to work with the bad guys in an effort to be a front for the underground or something (His plants turn out defective military equipment for the Nazis!). Somehow or other there are two other English soldiers posing as German soldiers and they all hook up with Duke and there's an old British guy that had been pretending to be an old German official, but was really a British secret agent and it all adds up to a big car chase and Duke escape. Michelle learns that Robert is not the biggest dog log on the planet next to Bud Selig, but more noble than Ghandi, Mother Teresa, and Nancy Reagan all put together. She immediately runs back to him and is ready to begin her life as faux-Nazi suck up. I'm glad that she's more than willing to do her part by living a cushy and glamourous existence and that somehow this will trick the Nazis into losing the war. She's a regular Mrs. Miniver!

A terrible, unbelievable story that makes little sense on any level and is topped off by the fact that you don't believe anything the stars do in this movie (except for when Duke slugs that Nazi). While Crawford and Wayne might have been perfect for one of those mismatched buddy movies (a la Turner & Hooch), they generate nothing other than to show us what would have happened to Casablanca if it had been hampered by a dull as dirt story (both in smarts, action, and emotion) and stars that thought mouthing bogus platitudes saluting the courage of a people who rolled over like they were the New Jersey Nets or something was somehow inspiring a multitude of people to keep fighting the good fight (or in the French case, to start fighting). Duke and Crawford's scenes could have been filmed on separate sets as little as the played off one another. They wanted us to think there was some love triangle, but Duke just would periodically grab and kiss her or say he loved her, while she would turn her nose up at him. All the while everyone (including Michelle) figured that Robert was a dirtbag conspirator, so he wasn't even in the picture (I don't think Duke and Robert even ever had a scene together). Suffice it to say, the love triangle bit flopped along with everything else in this hasty stew of war time posturing and cliches. Sit through this abominable entry in the "Rah, Rah, Rah! Go Allies!" film genre and you understand what they're talking about when you hear people say "war is hell!"

Reviews © 2004 MonsterHunter